Sightings - Podcast Rankings and reviews

I binged 4 episodes after listening for the first time, it is that good. Professionally done, engaging storytelling, interesting topics, ending with an analysis of whether the phenomenon is plausible or clearly a hoax. Love it.

I just started listening to this today, and I am obsessed. I listened to 2 episodes while at work, and it made my shift go by so quickly! Wonderful storytelling with a nice discussion at the ending. I 100% recommend!

I’ve tried most of the paranormal anthology shows and this one has both the best writing and narration out there. Both of these gentlemen are experienced and it shows. As a bonus, they spend a short time discussing the “true story” source material and it’s plausibility following the story.
I just wish there were more than 6 episodes so far as I binged those in one afternoon.

This show’s audio is incredibly impressive; the voice acting, storytelling, and topics are clearly very thoughtfully chosen. I’d argue it creates the same effect as if I am watching a thriller movie, which I find quite hard for podcasts to achieve. I wouldn’t consider myself a “big podcast person”, but this one has me hooked!

These two are clearly not well versed in these stories of high strangeness. Then the writer just makes up stuff to fill in the gaps or make it a better story. I just listened to the Loch Ness episode and could not believe my ears. I’ve heard a great deal of Nessie stories but this sounded like the script of a terrible SyFy channel movie. This podcast is more a kin to creepy pasta than any other show approaching the subject matter seriously. If you’re into high strangeness, I would look elsewhere.