Otherworld

Jack & Chelsea [Patreon Preview]

For Jack & Chelsea, what began as an exciting move into a charming, historic Cincinnati house full of parties and roommates devolved into a nightmare. At first, strange t

Episode 182 - Close to Home

During covid, Charlotte and her partner are hanging out in the backyard when they see something strange in the distance that slowly makes it's way uncomfortably close. T

Episode 181 - The Accident

While working at a summer camp Finn is in a freak accident that leaves him with a severe leg injury with lasting complications. Years later, while training to become a ma

Saving the Integratron Archive [Patreon Preview]

In this episode, I’m joined by Daniel Paul, Theo Schafer, and Theo Krantz to celebrate the culmination of our year-and-a-half-long side quest to preserve a major piece of

Episode 180 - The Treehouse

After his family moves into an old hunting cabin outside of San Diego, David strikes up a friendship with someone that may not be amongst the living. Once renovations beg

Island Lore with Caribbean Mystics [Patreon Preview]

Gabby Querrard and Paulina Creque of the podcast Caribbean Mystics join Jack on Patreon to discuss local paranormal stories from their home, the Virgin Islands, and the C

Episode 179: The Other Sam

While in high school, Forrest befriends a boy named Sam, who begins exhibiting strange behavior. During their hangouts, Sam sometimes seems to slip into an alternate pers

Episode 178: Beyond the Wall Pt. 2

In Part 2 of Beyond The Wall, Nina returns to her body and finds herself still held captive, in a new location and severely injured after an unknown amount of time has pa

Episode 177: Beyond the Wall Pt. 1

In 1989, shortly after the fall of the Berlin Wall, Nina was on the street outside her workplace when she was approached by a man identifying himself as a police officer.

Summer Camp [Patreon Preview]

This is a short preview of a patreon bonus episode that features two stories, both about camping. If you want to hear the full version, you can hear it right now at www.p

Episode 176: Flesh of the Gods

When Andrea loses her grandmother and is plunged into the depths of grief, she calls out and asks her for a sign. To her surprise, she woke up that night in another realm

Episode 175: I Met God in a Burger King Parking Lot

Paul was driving up to Virginia to see his girlfriend at the time when he came across a hitchhiker. This man asked to be dropped off at a Burger King close to where Paul

The Hat Man Project Project [Patreon Preview]

In this patreon episode, Jack and Trevor McFedries try to help Tim, the creator of the Hat Man Project, recover the website and restore one of the largest collections of

Episode 174: Save The Garden

When Mary was 18 years old she woke up paralyzed in the middle of the night to strange troll-like beings surrounding her bed, while a different, taller being observed fro

The Tip of Atlantis [Patreon Preview]

In this patreon episode, comic book and storyboard artist Mike Feehan (DC Comics, Marvel Studios) joins the show to unpack the bizarre life of Geoff Stirling, a media mog

Episode 173: Homecoming Night

When it's homecoming night at Matteson's high school, he decides to throw the afterparty for his tight-knit group of friends in his backyard. Living in a small, rural tow

Episode 172: Sector X

Whenever Eric and his high school friends had free time, they enjoyed exploring abandoned places, especially Arnold Heights, a deserted former military housing community.

Episode 171: The Widower

When Ashley was only 11 years old, she moved back to her parent's home country of Mexico. While the transition was difficult at first, she came to love her new life. Most

Freddy [Patreon Preview]

One day when Frank was 14 growing up in Tampa, FL, his dad came home from work and started talking about some guys from work who had a ghost in their office. Apparently,

Episode 170: The Restaurant Mimic

As a teenager, Tatum decided to take up a job at a small family-owned restaurant in Carlisle, Pennsylvania that was originally a historic pre-civil war home. As a nod to