Our curated selection of reviews
These are well-written and truly bone-chilling! I was absolutely enthralled as the story got more and more sinister. The voice acting is also really engaging, and the sound design really immersive.
When the story ends in a twist, I rarely see it coming, and even when I do, it’s usually so well-formed I am delightfully surprised anyway. Can’t recommend this series enough. I’m hooked, and I dread getting caught up and having to wait between seasons.
Read more
The only reason this isn’t getting a full five stars is because of the lackluster 6th season. The overly cinematic episodes (to the point where they’re corny) take out the core identity of the whole podcast: the spooky storytelling with the chill of a campfire. I hope season seven returns to their old way of storytelling.
Read more
I have been listing since season two, I love this podcast SO much I haven’t been able to find anything else like it. It’s so immersive and the voice acting is amazing I truly recommend to anyone! I do wish they gave us more,if I could recommend one episode it would be too many clowns season 6 the projector season 4 I think both amazing episodes!!!
Read more
Every story on this podcast draws me in more and more! I cannot get enough and look forward to new seasons every year—and of course I replay the current episodes while I wait! Absolutely chilling and thrilling!
Read more
Please bring back the authentic, campfire storytelling of prior seasons. This new season is so corny with the theatrics I have barely been able to get through a single episode. The intros and outtros are ridiculous and have nothing to do with the plot. “Spooky” parts of the story are recycled throughout multiple episodes (like the whole “I saw an exact replica of myself” uncanny valley thing). I have been a full body chills listener since day 1 and unfortunately season 6 made me unfollow. Please bring back authentic storytelling!
Read more
I loooove this podcast, but this season is starting off slightly disappointing. The previous seasons had so much dimension to them. They were stories that would lead you down scary roads and take you on unexpected twists. Now, when I listen, I’m sitting wondering if we will ever get to the point/plot. The creative writing seems to have been replaced with extremities of gore and profanities. They used to feel like those scary campfire stories you’d compete with your friends to tell, but now they just feel like a battle of which episode will make you want to vomit. I’ll continue to listen though because I stand behind this podcast. The theme song still gets me amped every time! Hoping as we get closer to Halloween, the new episodes bring what the old ones did -the true fright factor.
Update to add: what are these readings added at the end? Didn’t think season 6 could get any worse. 🤦🏻♀️ pleeeease go back to the OG stories. The ones that pulled us into this podcast. Bc this season ain’t it.
Read more
We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts