Will Sharpe (The White Lotus) hosts a mind-bending real-life story of reincarnation and a spooky tale of family secrets. In 1950s England, milkman John Pollock makes a sensational prophecy: His dead daughters will be reborn. At first, even his own wife says he’s a crank. But then she gives birth to twin girls who have uncanny similarities to their sisters who died. Suddenly, the world sits up and takes notice. Pollock’s prophecy attracts the attention of a serious American scientist who crosses the Atlantic countless times to study the twins. And his conclusion is astonishing. So, what if death is only the beginning? Extrasensory goes in search of the two people who know the truth—the twins themselves.
Extrasensory is an Apple Original podcast produced by Blanchard House. Follow and listen on Apple Podcasts.
apple.co/Extrasensory
Chart trend
Position in the True Crime chart (US), last 90 days.
#1#99#197JunAugSep
#9
all-time peak
1
day in the top 10 since Nov 2024
Latest episodes
Showing 9 · updated from the feed
Isn’t Love Enough? | 8
In the season finale, there’s a shocking twist just as the truth of the Pollock story seems to be becoming clear. An astonishing new version of events emerges. Stevenson
Dec 9 2024 44 min
Seeing Is Believing | 7
The bombshells about John Pollock sink in. Producer Poppy steps up the search for Jennifer Pollock, one of the twins. Doubts are raised over a photo of the Pollock twins.
Dec 2 2024 33 min
The Two Johns | 6
John’s granddaughters Liza and Joanna speak out about the reincarnation story for the first time. Shocking revelations emerge about John and his version of events. Liza a
Nov 25 2024 36 min
Doubt | 5
John makes an extraordinary new claim. Stevenson tends to his wife on her deathbed, then throws himself back into his reincarnation work. John gets the opportunity to tes
Nov 18 2024 31 min
Dead Reckoning | 4
A film crew arrives to make a major TV documentary about the Pollocks, but the producer suspects the twins are holding something back. Stevenson’s big benefactor dies, le
Nov 11 2024 32 min
Bad Trip | 3
Stevenson puts John and Florence’s claims to the test and subjects them to some tough questioning. A visit to the Pollocks’ old neighborhood reveals further jaw-dropping
Nov 4 2024 39 min
One White Crow | 2
In the U.S., a university professor is under fire for studying reincarnation. Dr. Ian Stevenson needs just one compelling case to silence his enemies. He decides to pay t
Oct 28 2024 35 min
The Prophet | 1
In 1950s England, milkman John Pollock makes an astonishing prediction about his dead daughters. John’s wife Florence thinks he’s crazy—until she gives birth to twins. Jo
Oct 28 2024 41 min
Introducing Extrasensory
In 1950s England, milkman John Pollock makes a sensational prophecy: His dead daughters will be reborn. At first, even his own wife says he’s a crank. But then she gives
Oct 21 2024 2 min
Chart positions
Where Extrasensory ranks today in each Apple Podcasts chart (US, Sep 5, 2026).
A curated, balanced selection of Apple Podcasts reviews.
Gripping from the beginning, but does start to drag on in the middle. The jumping back and forth between dates was a little unnecessary. Overall it is a good and entertaining story; whether or not you believe it was true, false, or somewhere in the middle. It was fun to hear what happened and what this family believed (or didn’t) of it. I hope Extrasensory continues with more stories and isn’t a one season thing.
brilliantcynic · Feb 2026
This podcast was so good. I loved that they’re reached into all avenues of the story and gave a well rounded view. I’d never heard of the Pollock twins and their story was so interesting. Blanchard House really does a good job. The narrator, interviews and voice actors added to the story without overdoing.
K_merr · Jan 2026
An outstanding show/documentary about the Pollock twins, their family and an authors (Stevenson) life long research into reincarnation. All presented in an informative AND entertaining way! Highly recommended.
Johnnyboy5075 · Dec 2025
I believe that the best narratives engage in accurate, in-depth research and ultimately invite their audience to draw their own conclusions. As a person with a journalism degree and an appreciate for a great narrative, I would not have done a single thing differently. I think the best stories are those in which there are multiple perspectives. I glanced at a few reviews and see that people are irritated by a certain level of production when it comes to sound. To each their own, but I think it’s unfair to base an entire review on one element. Will Sharpe was a terrific host. I recommend this podcast to anyone who likes to listen to multiple perspectives and draw their own conclusions.
EmilyEU · Nov 2025
I went in expecting a good story but what I got was a repetitive, poorly constructed piece of narrative manipulation with silly sound effects. They took what few facts there were, leaned on secondary sources for episodes, twisted them into a pretzel, and presented them episodes long as the main narrative. All I could think "where's the actual evidence?". And the ending... don't even get me started..The whole thing felt dishonest and manipulative.
Thomas oxe · Dec 2024
This had all the makings of a great story - weird, mysterious and true. But using fictionalized narrative, bad voice actors, and weak scripting to make it sound like an old school radio mystery robbed it of what might have made it compelling and unique. Disappointing.
Heyjoelle · Nov 2024
We strive to present a balanced view by showing a diverse range of reviews from Apple Podcasts.
More podcasts like Extrasensory
Popular shows in True Crime, for your next listen.
Here you find the Apple Podcasts chart positions of Extrasensory, its latest episodes to listen to directly, and reviews from listeners. Rankings are updated daily for the United States.
