Extrasensory - Podcast Rankings and reviews

Excellent series. Twists and turns you don’t see coming, very well researched, very well written, great storytelling. I wanted to binge the whole thing right away but I also wanted to savor it and look forward to the next episode. (All right, I binged it in the course of 5 days, lol). I really hope there is a Season 2.

Very interesting, well-told story. Kept me engaged and wanting more. The twists and turns and mystery surrounding it was great! 10/10 recommend!

I don’t write reviews but I’m obsessed with this podcast. Host is compelling, subject is fascinating; seems thoroughly researched. I can’t wait for the resolution.

This series was amazing! I listened to the entire thing in 2 days because I just couldn’t get enough!!! As someone who is also a spiritualist and studying para-psychology, this was incredible from beginning to end!

I went in expecting a good story but what I got was a repetitive, poorly constructed piece of narrative manipulation with silly sound effects. They took what few facts there were, leaned on secondary sources for episodes, twisted them into a pretzel, and presented them episodes long as the main narrative. All I could think "where's the actual evidence?". And the ending... don't even get me started..The whole thing felt dishonest and manipulative.

This had all the makings of a great story - weird, mysterious and true. But using fictionalized narrative, bad voice actors, and weak scripting to make it sound like an old school radio mystery robbed it of what might have made it compelling and unique. Disappointing.